Why isn't my compressed file smaller?
Because it was already compressed. JPG photos, MP4 videos, MP3 audio and most PDFs exported by modern software are stored in compressed form, so a second pass at a similar quality finds little left to remove. Typical cases:
- PDF. Adobe Acrobat, current Word and Apple Pages exports are well optimised already, and text-only PDFs have almost nothing to shrink: text and vector graphics are tiny compared with images. If the embedded images are already at or below the preset's resolution, downsampling does nothing. On Compress PDF, move from Ebook (150 DPI) to Screen (72 DPI); if that is still too large, split the document and compress the parts.
- Images. A JPG saved at a modest quality barely shrinks at the same quality. The Image compressor lets you set a target file size, which forces the quality down until the target is met; for a PNG with photographic content, converting to JPG or WEBP (PNG to JPG, JPG to WEBP) saves far more than recompressing the PNG.
- Video. A video that is already at a low bitrate will not get smaller without lowering the resolution or the bitrate. Compress MP4 and the Video compressor offer a target file size, a quality setting, and resolution presets; dropping 4K to 1080p, or 1080p to 720p, is the single biggest saving.
- Audio. Compress MP3 reduces the bitrate; 128 kbit/s is a sensible floor for music, 64 kbit/s for speech.
A result that is a few percent smaller, or occasionally a little larger, means the input was already efficient. Compression is lossy: each pass at a lower quality discards detail, so keep the original and compress from it rather than re-compressing a compressed file.